User uShare Login | Register

Along with posting photos, videos, and stories, your uShare account lets you post Classified Ads, recipes on What's For Dinner, and Announcements.

20° View Weather Current Conditions Sioux Falls Change Location
Set Weather Options



Significant snowfall for KELOLAND on Monday. Click Here For Storm Center Update. | Sioux Falls News & Weather, South Dakota News & Weather, Minnesota and Iowa News

[0] My Saved Articles
Find local businesses
on the KELO Pages!


Some Question Fairness In Wright Trial

April 6, 2007, 4:24 PM by Lou Raguse

Some Question Fairness In Wright Trial
A week into Daphne Wright's murder trial, and some deaf people around the country still wonder whether it's possible for her to get a fair trial. 

Wright's lawyers say she's fairly intelligent; her IQ is 110. But the deaf woman only reads English at a third-grade level.

Photo: Daphne Wright

That leads some activists to question whether the courtroom accommodations are enough to make sure she understands the proceedings.

Wright uses American Sign Language, which isn't just the English language spelled out into signs. ASL is its own language, with different sentence structures than English. So even though the judge took some extra steps to accommodate her in the courtroom for the trial, some people think Wright still has trouble understanding everything that's going on.

Deaf civil rights activist Elizabeth Gillespie from Maryland runs a blog, commenting on issues involving deaf people around the country. In recent weeks, her topic of choice has been the murder trial of Daphne Wright, the deaf woman accused of murdering and dismembering another deaf woman, Darlene VanderGiesen. 

Gillespie immediately wondered whether Wright can fully understand what's said in the courtroom. In an online interview with KELOLAND News she writes:

"I am impressed with the efforts of her lawyer. She is trying her best. But unfortunately, I don't feel [Wright] is getting a fair trial due to the denial of a certified deaf interpreter."

Wright understands ASL, or American Sign Language. But she's not as proficient in written English. That was evident in court this week as prosecutors introduced notes she wrote while being investigated. Wright's sentences are not grammatically correct, in part, because of the translation that's lost through ASL to English. 

That's why Gillespie says courtroom accommodations like this real-time text translator don't necessarily help Wright. 

The courtroom interpreters in Wright's trial do translate the spoken English into ASL. But Gillespie worries, with the speed everyone talks and all the complicated concepts in a courtroom, the interpreters would have trouble clearly translating everything. 

Gillespie writes: "This would be very difficult to do if the interpreting is simultaneous" 

A certified deaf interpreter, which Gillespie believes Wright needs, is a second interpreter who, like the defendant, is deaf. The CDI would watch the main interpreter then retranslate everything to Wright to ensure comprehension. The defense asked a CDI, but Judge Brad Zell rejected the request in an earlier hearing, determining that the interpretation is sufficient.

Previous Story

Next Story




You may also like

Ronald Neels Sentenced To 75 Years In Prison

11/23/2015 5:59 PM

For more than a decade, nobody knew Ronald Neels was sexually abusing a victim inside his home near Garretson. The victim never said anything about th...

Full Story | Watch
Roslyn Man Arrested In Shooting

11/21/2015 4:46 PM

A Roslyn, South Dakota man is accused of trying to kill another man overnight.

Full Story
Harrisburg High School Wins $100,000

11/25/2015 9:01 AM

Students at Harrisburg High School are celebrating Wednesday morning.

Full Story
Tyrese Ruffin's Mother Speaks Publicly For First Time

11/25/2015 6:18 AM

In her first and only television interview, Doohen talked about her son, who she called the joy of her life.

Full Story
LHS Student Charged With Making Bomb Threat

11/23/2015 10:53 AM

Sioux Falls Police said a 16-year-old student wrote a message on a bathroom mirror.

Full Story