KELOLAND.com Search   Advanced Search.RSS Story Links
Online Opinion Poll
Online Opinion is your chance to tell Keloland what you think.
Remember - our on-air polls are scientific. Online Opinion is not. It's simply an easy way to speak your mind.

As of today, 574 questions have been posted and 1,066,602 votes have been cast. Click Here to view the Online Opinion archives.


Feb 26, 2008
The American Left and Cuba's Independent Librarians
Posted by: Ken Blanchard - 02/26/2008 1:02 AM (Cuba, Freedom of Thought)


Much of the American left continues to admire and support Castro's regime. 

Consider the case of the American Library Association and the Independent Library Project in Cuba.  If you are one of those Cubans who doesn't have the "convertible pesos," and you want to get books that the Castro regime doesn't approve of, you have to find an independent book lender. And you would have to convince the book lender that you are not a government agent, because the government's response to this movement is to arrest and imprison the independent librarians. 

Now you might think that the American Library Association, which categorically "deplores any restrictions ... that inhibit the free flow of information among librarians", to side with the Independent Library Project in Cuba.  You would be wrong.  The ALA Latin American and Caribbean Subcommittee (of the International Relations Committee), refused to recommend that the ALA condemn the Cuban government's treatment of independent librarians.  After hearing both sides, those who favor the Cuban government and those who are being thrown in the slammer, the LAC Subcommittee issued a report.  Here is a juicy passage:

Data presented on both sides of the issue are inconclusive, with each side questioning both the accuracy and the intention of the other. While the civil oppression of individuals associated with these collections appears to be documented by Amnesty International and other observers, it is not conclusive whether these conditions result from the denial of intellectual freedom or from anti-government activities by the persons involved. The "independent" nature of the various collections of books and other documents, as well as the political agenda of those individuals responsible for them, are questionable, but seem to represent the political orientation of special interests positioned in opposition to the Cuban government.

Let me unpack that for you.  The Cuban government regards independent librarians as agents of outside powers, hostile to Cuban socialism.  That, of course, is how tyrannies view any attempt at freedom of thought: it is treason against the state.  The ALAsubcommittee endorses this view.  Because the independent librarians get help (see: books) from folks outside Cuba who are not fond of the Cuban regime (where else would they get them?  Not, I think, from the ALA), they are therefore not really "independent." 

Of course that doesn't mean that the ALA doesn't take sides.  It is firmly on the side of the regime. 

During the discussion, Ms. Neugebauer affirmed her belief that any condemnation by ALA at this point, based on information that may be inaccurate and politically loaded, could be offensive to library colleagues in Cuba and might harm the peer relationships American librarians are trying to develop with Cuban librarians.

Of course the "library colleagues in Cuba" aren't "independent" either.  They are creatures of the regime.  The ALA has made it clear whose side it is on.

 

Comments

There are no comments at this time.

Post a Comment
Name

Email

Remember my information?
Yes No

Subscribe to this comment thread?
Yes No
Comments



Enter the word in the image for verification.

 

Web Site Design and Custom Programming By: Lawrence & Schiller© 2010 KELO-TV -- KELOLAND.COM -- ALL RIGHTS RESERVED